- The Railroad InnCooperstown8.9
- Lake View MotelCooperstown8.6
- Holiday Inn Express Oneonta by IHG8.7Oneonta
- Quality Inn Oneonta Cooperstown Area8.1Oneonta
- 5 Mi to Cooperstown All Star Village Otego HomeOtego9.5
- Landmark Inn9.8Cooperstown
- Visions Inn7.5Cooperstown
- Whisperin' Pines ChaletCooperstown9.5
- Mohican MotelCooperstown8.2
- Bayside Inn & Marina9.1Cooperstown
- Cooperstown Bed and Breakfast9.5Cooperstown
- August Lodge Cooperstown9.0Hartwick Seminary
- Baseball Town MotelCooperstown7.9
- The White House InnCooperstown9.1
- The Otesaga Resort HotelCooperstown9.3
- Hampton Inn Oneonta8.8Oneonta
- Motel 886.7Oneonta
- Best Western Cooperstown7.9Cooperstown
- Hickory Grove Motor Inn - CooperstownCooperstown7.9
- Courtyard by Marriott Oneonta8.9Oneonta
- Lake Front Hotel7.8Cooperstown
- Kountry Living Bed and BreakfastOneonta9.7
- Allen Lake Resort Richfield Springs Cooperstown9.2Richfield Springs
- Lake 'N Pines MotelCooperstown8.4
- The Marx Hotel - Downtown - University Area6.7Oneonta
- The Tunnicliff InnCooperstown7.5
- Super 8 by Wyndham Oneonta/Cooperstown7.0Oneonta
- Comfort Inn & Suites Cooperstown - Milford8.0Cooperstown
- Apple Inn and Suites Cooperstown Area9.4Milford
- Holiday Inn Express & Suites Cooperstown by IHG8.9Cooperstown
- Rose & Thistle Bed & BreakfastCooperstown9.6
- End of results -