- Double Play Apt 2 All Star Baseball RentalsOneonta
- Cloud CrowdBloomville
- Burlington Flats House Less Than 13 Mi to Cooperstown!Fly Creek8.5
- After the Game Apt 1 All Star Baseball RentalsOneonta
- Otego Home with Hot Tub Near All Star Village!Oneonta
- Elenas by the MillEast Meredith7.3
- Grand Slam Lake House Cooperstown Dreams ParkCooperstown
- Bloom Farm GuesthouseMount Vision9.6
- After the Game Apt 2 All Star Baseball RentalsOneonta9.3
- Home Plate Apt 2 All Star Baseball RentalsOneonta
- Upstate New York Vacation Rental Near Cooperstown!Cherry Valley8.9
- Fire Pit and Gas Grill Secluded Studio in Milford!Milford7.8
- Country Escape with Sauna, 10 Mi to CooperstownRichfield Springs9.3
- Unadilla Cabin on 50 Acres and Fire Pit and CreekUnadilla9.0
- Catskills Enchanted ForestBloomville8.0
- The Hill All Star Baseball RentalsOneonta
- Quiet Country Escape Fire Pit, Fish On-Site!Leonardsville10.0
- Double Play Apt 1 All Star Baseball RentalsOneonta
- 1st Base Apt 1 All Star Baseball RentalsOneonta8.0
- The Hidden InnSouth Kortright8.2
- Rustic Bainbridge Retreat with Spacious Yard!
- 1st Base Apt 2 All Star Baseball RentalsOneonta9.0
- Upstate getaway. Leave your troubles behind.Unadilla
- BBQ Ready Lakeside Milford Home with PaddleboatMilford10.0
- Doyle House - Near Cooperstown Dreams Park 2Milford9.8
- Catskills Mountain Cabin in Bloomville!Stamford8.0
- Oneida Lodge NorthCooperstown
- Renovated Catskills Farmhouse with Game Room!Treadwell9.0
- Cozy Milford Cottage on Half Acre w Deck & GrillMilford8.0
- A Bonnie PlaceOneonta10.0
- Catskills Farmhouse and Spa
- Silver Lake Cabin w/ Own Lake! (near Cooperstown)New Berlin
- Lil' RitaBloomville9.0
- Countryside Hideaway - 10 Mi to Cooperstown!9.3
- Seneca LodgeCooperstown10.0
- 1st Class Rentals The Thurman Munson HouseCooperstown9.5
- Less Than 4 Mi to Cooperstown Charming Historic Home!Fly Creek9.0
- Home Plate Apt 1 All Star Baseball RentalsOneonta
- Stella FirmaBloomville
- Cayuga Lodge SouthCooperstown10.0
- End of results -