- Hilltop Villas at Bluebeard's CastleCharlotte Amalie8.7
- Coconut Coast VillasContant9.0
- The Westin St. John Resort Villas9.1Saint John
- The Cottage at Villa IndigoCharlotte Amalie7.5
Little Indigo ApartmentsMafolie6.7- Casa Azul9.5
- Lindbergh Bay Hotel6.9Lindbergh Bay
- Secret Harbour Beach Resort8.4St Thomas
- The Mafolie Hotel7.8Mafolie
- Sapphire Beach Resort and MarinaSt Thomas8.6
- End of results -