- Michelin GuideThe Lightkeeper’s InnEdgartown
- Summer DazeEdgartown10.0
Michelin GuideAquinnah Cliffs- Old OrchardEdgartown8.8
- The RootskellerOak Bluffs
- Island DreamOak Bluffs
- Easy Access to Beaches: Vineyard Haven HouseVineyard Haven10.0
Michelin GuideMartha's Vineyard- Family-Friendly Tisbury Escape - Walk to TownVineyard Haven9.6
Michelin GuideWoods Hole Oceanographic InstitutionWoods Hole- Falmouth TidesFalmouth9.0
Michelin GuideWoods Hole Science AquariumWoods Hole- West Tisbury InnWest Tisbury8.4
Michelin GuideOak BluffsOak Bluffs- Harbor Cove CottageEdgartown7.6
- South Cape EscapeNew Seabury10.0
- Michelin GuideThe Sydney, The Edgartown CollectionEdgartown
- Michelin GuideThe Richard, The Edgartown CollectionEdgartown
- End of results -