- Inn of the Lost CoastShelter Cove8.5
- Lone Pine MotelGarberville6.8
- China Creek CottagesWillow Creek8.2
- Victorian Inn8.4Ferndale
- Hampton Inn & Suites Arcata8.7Arcata
- Ramada Bayside Inn & Suites Eureka7.0Eureka
- Dean Creek Resort8.0Redway
Best Western Plus Humboldt House Inn7.0Garberville- The Redwood Riverwalk, a boutique hotel6.5Fortuna
- Emerald Forest CabinsTrinidad8.9
- End of results -