- Julie's Park Cafe & MotelFish Creek9.0
- Snug Harbor Inn8.8Sturgeon Bay
- The Wanderlust HotelSturgeon Bay8.8
- The Landing Resort8.6Egg Harbor
- Cedar Court InnFish Creek8.5
- Parkside InnEllison Bay8.6
- Spruce & Shore Motel8.9Fish Creek
- The Scofield House B&BSturgeon Bay9.9
- Bay Breeze ResortEphraim9.0
- Harbor Guest HouseFish Creek9.4
- Eagle Harbor Inn8.9Ephraim
- The Foxglove InnSturgeon Bay9.4
- The Inn at Little Sister Hill8.7Sister Bay
- Lull-Abi Inn7.4Egg Harbor
- AmericInn by Wyndham Menominee8.6Menominee
- AmericInn by Wyndham Sturgeon Bay8.0Sturgeon Bay
- Homestead Suites - Fish CreekFish Creek8.8
- Baymont by Wyndham Marinette7.9Marinette
- Quality Inn & Suites Marinette6.8Marinette
- Somerset Inn & Suites9.0Ephraim
- Open Hearth Lodge9.4Sister Bay
- Newport Resort8.8Egg Harbor
- Westwood Shores Waterfront Resort9.3Sturgeon Bay
- The Water Street InnEphraim9.5
- White Birch InnSturgeon Bay6.4
- Main Street MotelFish Creek9.4
- High Point Inn8.9Ephraim
- Baileys Sunset MotelBaileys Harbor7.4
- Best Western Maritime Inn7.3Sturgeon Bay
- Country House Resort9.3Sister Bay
- Pine Grove ResortEphraim8.9
- Evergreen Hill Condominiums9.0Fish Creek
- Parkwood Lodge8.5Fish Creek
- End of results -