- Put-in-Bay Victory Station3.0Put-in-Bay
- Farrell House Lodge at Sunnybrook Trout Club9.8Sandusky
- South Shore Inn8.4Sandusky
- Islander InnPut-in-Bay8.3
- Cedar Stables Inn & SuitesSandusky8.2
- Put-in-Bay Condos7.6Put-in-Bay
- Sleep Inn Sandusky6.9Sandusky
- Spacious Lakeside Cottage - 2 Miles to Marblehead!Lakeside7.5
- Commodore Resort4.8Put-in-Bay
- Lake Point MotelMarblehead8.8
- Rodeway Inn North5.8Sandusky
- Grand Islander HotelPut-in-Bay6.8
- Aunt Jane's Victorian ManorPut-in-Bay7.6
- Quality Inn near Cedar Point - Huron, Sandusky OH6.9Huron
- Holiday Inn Express Hotel & Suites Port Clinton-Catawba Island by IHG8.0Port Clinton
- Hampton Inn Sandusky-Central8.8Sandusky
- Holiday Inn Express Vermilion by IHG8.3Vermilion
- Quality Inn & Suites Sandusky8.1Sandusky
- Baymont by Wyndham Sandusky6.1Sandusky
- Castaway Bay by Cedar Point Resorts8.2Sandusky
- Super 8 by Wyndham Port Clinton7.4Port Clinton
- Holiday Inn Express & Suites - Milan - Sandusky Area by IHG9.0Milan
- Bay Lodging Resort7.1Put-in-Bay
- Hampton Inn and Suites Sandusky/Milan8.8Milan
- Ahoy Inn GuesthousePut-in-Bay9.2
- Little Ted's CottagesMarblehead8.4
- Fairfield by Marriott Port Clinton Waterfront8.8Port Clinton
- Sleep Inn & Suites Port Clinton8.2Port Clinton
- Clinton Inn & Suites6.4Port Clinton
- Cedar Point's Express Hotel7.9Sandusky
- Red Roof Inn Sandusky - Milan7.9Milan
- Holiday Inn Express & Suites Sandusky by IHG8.2Sandusky
- Sawmill Creek by Cedar Point Resorts8.8Sandusky
- Plantation Motel7.7Huron
- Cedar Point's Lighthouse PointSandusky8.3
- Great Wolf Lodge Sandusky8.1Sandusky
- Arlington Inn7.3Port Clinton
- Econo Lodge Inn & Suites South7.8Sandusky
- Put-in-Bay Waterfront Condo #206Put-in-Bay
- Motel 6-Milan, OH - Sandusky7.1Milan
- End of results -