- Rustic EleganceHimrod9.3
- Vinifera InnGeneva8.0
- Inn at Taughannock FallsIthaca9.2
- Yale Manor B&B & Yurt GlampingYale8.7
- The Gridley Inn B&BWaterloo8.7
- Barrister's Bed & BreakfastSeneca Falls9.7
- Boat, Grill and Unwind Lakefront Cayuga Home!Aurora
- Forever Red Cottage on Cayuga LakeSeneca Falls
- Del Lago Resort & Casino8.8Waterloo
- Seneca Falls Cottage on Cayuga Lake Wine Trail!Seneca Falls6.0
- 1 Block to Dtwn Seneca Falls Apartment with Yard!Seneca Falls10.0
- The Boat HouseCayuga
- Gould Swaby MansionSeneca Falls
- Finger Lakes Retreat with Sunroom, Fire Pit and BBQ!Himrod10.0
- Waterfront Seneca Lake House Fire Pit and Boat DockGeneva
- Home 1 Mi to Its A Wonderful Life Museum and Dtwn!Seneca Falls
- Glass Magnolia Bed & BreakfastInterlaken9.0
- NEW Cayuga, Hot Tub, Dog Friendly, Wine TrailCayuga
- Black Walnut Bed and BreakfastInterlaken9.0
- Unique Ovid Apt with Grill on Cayuga Wine Trail!Ovid9.0
- Deck and Game Room Finger Lakes Family RetreatLansing
- Fingerlakes farm with goats & chickensAuburn
- The Lux Hotel & Conference Center, Ascend Hotel Collection8.0Waterloo
- Hampton Inn Geneva7.3Geneva
- 41 Lakefront Hotel, Trademark Collection by Wyndham7.8Geneva
- Hampton Inn Seneca FallsSeneca Falls8.4
- Cozy & Quiet Lakeside RetreatAurora
- Tillinghast Manor Bed & BrunchOvid9.7
- Savannah House Wine Country Inn & Cottages9.2Himrod
- Geneva On The Lake Boutique Resort HotelGeneva8.4
- The Fox and the GrapesLodi9.6
- The Gould Hotel8.4Seneca Falls
- OYO Hotel Starlite Seneca Falls5.8Seneca Falls
- End of results -