- The Outlier InnWoodridge9.0
- Wallkill 4BR Retreat Large Yard Pet FriendlyWallkill
- SureStay Plus Hotel by Best Western Highland Poughkeepsie7.7Highland
- Hampton Inn by Hilton New Paltz, NYNew Paltz9.1
- The Gables of Rhinebeck9.0Rhinebeck
- UpdatedandPet-Friendly Cabin By Hikes and Woodstock!Bearsville8.8
- Margaretville Mountain Inn B&B8.9Margaretville
- Village Suites5.7Margaretville
- Romantic, Magical Cottage in Catskills nr WoodstockWillow9.3
- Village MotelEllenville7.3
- Rondout Valley Camping Resort Deluxe Park Model 11Accord8.5
- Dome Compound with Hot Tub, Piano and Rock-Climbing GymNew Paltz
- Hotel Dylan8.9Woodstock
- Church Des ArtistesKingston
- Mirbeau Inn & Spa, RhinebeckRhinebeck9.1
- The Kartrite Resort and Indoor WaterparkMonticello7.8
- Huge Modern Chalet on Trestle Trail New Paltz & RosendaleRosendale
- Ashokan Reservoir Treetop Suite in the CatskillsOlivebridge
- Lake House, Fire Pit, Kayaks Magnolia Lake HouseFerndale
- Newly Renovated 3BR Hudson Valley HouseUlster Park9.6
- ShadowcrestFleischmanns9.1
- Cute Cozy Cottage Glenford New York
- Stonehill's FarmhouseAccord9.1
- Starlite Motel & SuitesBig Indian8.4
- Margaretville Motel6.7Margaretville
- Modern Catskills Escape w Open Living Steam Shower Hot Tub w Mountain Views Minutes from Woodstock Trails Suncliff VistaShokan10.0
- Hudson Escape W Hot Tub Bridge ViewHighland
- Mink Hollow LodgeElka Park
- Elegantly English CatskillsLiberty9.3
- Resorts World Catskills8.2Monticello
- Courtyard by Marriott Kingston8.9Kingston
- Suites on MainMargaretville6.7
- Morning Glory B&BWoodstock8.3
- Breezy Hill Inn9.8Fleischmanns
- Minnewaska LodgeGardiner8.9
- The Carriage House Loft9.5Kingston
- Rodeway Inn & Suites New Paltz - Hudson Valley6.8New Paltz
- The StablesKingston10.0
- Slide Mountain Forest HouseOliverea8.9
- Holiday Inn Express & Suites Kingston-Ulster by IHG8.6Lake Katrine
- End of results -