- Buena Vista Inn Motel6.9Delhi
- Colonial InnPine Hill8.0
- Lakewood Lodge & RestaurantLakewood6.9
- Stamford Gables Bed and Breakfast9.8Stamford
- Division Champs 2 - All Star Baseball RentalsOneonta
- Bearpen Lodge on 125 Acres - Near Belleayre Mtn!Vega10.0
- KOA Catskill Mountains Dome 4Gilboa
- Margaretville Mountain Inn B&B8.9Margaretville
- Village Suites5.7Margaretville
- A River Runs Through ItEast Branch9.8
- Holiday Inn Express Oneonta by IHG8.7Oneonta
- Roscoe RetreatRoscoe9.2
- Quality Inn Oneonta Cooperstown Area7.8Oneonta
- 5 Mi to Cooperstown All Star Village Otego HomeOtego9.3
- Fern Hollow Home
- Mill Pond InnJefferson9.0
- Wind in the Willows OvernightJefferson9.6
- Pet-Friendly Catskills Home with Serene Pond!Jefferson
- Reynolds House innRoscoe8.0
- The Main Lineup 3 - All Star Baseball RentalsOneonta
- Serene Home with On-Site Brook in Callicoon CenterCallicoon Center
- KOA Catskill Mountains Dome 3Gilboa
- ShadowcrestFleischmanns9.1
- Roscoe Cabin Pet friendlyRoscoe10.0
- Lakeside Gem Hot Tub and Game Room in HancockDeposit
- The Franklin HouseFranklin
- Serene Retreat - 7 Mi to All Star VillageOtego10.0
- Hampton Inn Oneonta8.7Oneonta
- Starlite Motel & SuitesBig Indian8.4
- Margaretville Motel6.7Margaretville
- Motel 886.5Oneonta
- Pine Hill Arms Hotel7.5Pine Hill
- Courtyard by Marriott Oneonta8.8Oneonta
- Kountry Living Bed and BreakfastOneonta9.6
- Suites on MainMargaretville6.7
- The Marx Hotel - Downtown - University Area6.7Oneonta
- Breezy Hill Inn9.8Fleischmanns
- Super 8 by Wyndham Oneonta/Cooperstown6.8Oneonta
- Slide Mountain Forest HouseOliverea8.9
- Super 8 by Wyndham Sidney NY6.9Sidney
- End of results -