- SEA-estaFalmouth9.0
- The Eliot NoyesChilmark9.0
- Island Inn8.1Oak Bluffs
- Sands Of Time Motor Inn & Harbor House8.9Woods Hole
- Narragansett HouseOak Bluffs8.7
- Winnetu Oceanside Resort at South BeachEdgartown6.0
- InnSeason Resorts Captain's Quarters9.5Falmouth
- Island SanctuaryOak Bluffs7.7
- Treehouse LodgeWoods Hole8.8
- The Attleboro HouseOak Bluffs8.6
- Vineyard CharmEdgartown8.2
- Island GetawayOak Bluffs3.5
- Inkwell Beach Cottage8.6Oak Bluffs
- Lambert's Cove Inn & ResortWest Tisbury8.5
- InnSeason Resorts HarborWalk9.1Falmouth
- Winthrop CottageOak Bluffs8.0
- Inn on the Sound9.3Falmouth
- Hotel Cape Cod7.9Falmouth
- Harbor View Hotel9.0Edgartown
- Mariner Motel8.4Falmouth
- Falmouth Heights Motor Lodge9.0Falmouth
- Town & Beach Motel8.6Falmouth
- Edgar Hotel Martha's Vineyard, an Ascend Collection Hotel8.1Edgartown
- The Club at New SeaburyMashpee8.8
- The CAVU Mansion on BellevueOklahoma Heights7.1
- Beachside Village ResortFalmouth8.8
- Pequot Hotel8.9Oak Bluffs
- The Coonamessett8.0Falmouth
- Red Horse InnFalmouth9.2
- InnSeason Resorts Surfside9.0Falmouth
- The Oak Bluffs Inn9.7Oak Bluffs
- End of results -