- The Black Pearl, Waiheke Island9.5Oneroa
- Bella Seven- Stay WaihekeOneroa9.6
- The Sanctuary- Stay WaihekeOneroa1.0
- Cape Cottage - Stay WaihekeOneroa9.2
- Viewpoint - Stay WaihekeOnetangi9.6
- Waiheke Waters EdgeOmiha8.8
- The Nikau LoftOnetangi9.5
- Church Bay Views - Stay WaihekeOneroa8.8
- Onetangi Beach Apartments8.1Onetangi
- Watermark ApartmentsOneroa9.3
- Whisper CottageOnetangi9.1
- 16 Waikare - You've Got It MaidOneroa9.3
- Luxury at Palm Beach - You've Got It MaidPalm Beach8.8
- Tiri Cottage - Sea Views in Oneroa by Waiheke UnlimitedOneroa7.9
- Blackpool Boathouse - Stay WaihekeOneroa9.3
- The Lodge at MudbrickOneroa9.7
- Island Villa- Stay WaihekeOneroa8.8
- Palm HeightsPalm Beach8.7
- Palm Beach BungalowsPalm Beach8.2
- The Jazz LoftOnetangi5.9
- Bayview RetreatOneroa8.6
- Number Six - Oneroa Holiday HomeOneroa9.1
- Island BreezeOneroa9.1
- Putaki Bay - Tui Villa - Be My Guest WaihekeTe Whau Bay9.0
- Ridge Cottage - Oneroa Holiday HomeOneroa6.0
- The Little Blue Bach in Oneroa Village by Waiheke UnlimitedOneroa8.9
- Waiheke Island OneroaOneroa8.6
- No 63 - Stay WaihekeOnetangi9.0
- Vista Twenty One - Stay WaihekeOnetangi8.8
- Number Five - Stay WaihekeOnetangi7.8
- The Villino at Cypress Ridge Estate - Stay WaihekeOnetangi9.8
- The Vineyard Cottage - Stay WaihekeOnetangi9.6
- Waiheke Island GuesthouseOstend8.1
- Kiwi House WaihekeOneroa8.7
- Le Chalet Waiheke ApartmentsOstend8.9
- Tutiri in Oneroa - Stay WaihekeOneroa9.6
- Waiheke Island Tawa Lodge - Adults OnlyOneroa8.9
- Relax on Ridge8.9Oneroa
- Waiheke Island Punga LodgeOneroa9.3
- Drop Anchor at Enclosure Bay Beach by Waiheke UnlimitedOneroa8.4
- End of results -